How to hire a private investigator—and get an answer you can use
You've decided you need some help investigating a situation, person, incident, loved one, business partner, or investment. If you've never used a private investigator ("PI") before, you're not alone.
While the days of dark fedoras, long trench coats, cigars, and whisky are over, it's a nice dramatization of what we do and how we do it. Nowadays, there's a huge divide in what private investigators do and will do. Make sure you do your research to find one who fits your needs and your goals. The cheap ones are not always the best—and, for that matter, I know plenty of expensive ones that are not the best either.
The better test is what an investigator can help you understand. Start with the decision you need to make and the fact that would help you make it. If you need to reach a witness, assess a business connection, or resolve a discrepancy in someone's background, that question gives an investigator something concrete to work on.
At Howler Investigative, you get personal attention, investigative judgment, and sourced written findings—not just a list of search results. We help you narrow the assignment, then connect records research, open-source intelligence, and analysis to the question you need answered. We'll recommend the work that fits, even if it differs from the service you first had in mind.
1. Turn your concern into a question an investigator can answer
Try finishing this sentence before you call:
I need to know ___ so I can decide ___ by ___.
Here are three ways that might sound. These are hypothetical examples of how to frame a request.
- “I need a current lead on how to reach a former employee so our legal team can contact them before a deadline.” A locate investigation can focus on that person and assess which leads are current enough to pursue.
- “I need to understand which companies or properties the records connect to this business before deciding what to do next.” An asset investigation can look for relevant property and business records and explain how they relate to the question.
- “Two records appear to describe the same person. Can we establish whether they do?” A background investigation can examine the identifying details and assess whether the records support a match.
You don't need to arrive with an investigation plan. Bring the situation in your own words. Howler helps identify the most useful question, especially when several facts are in dispute. That judgment helps keep the assignment focused on information that matters to your next decision.
2. Ask what the investigator would do with your question
Ask how to verify the firm's licensing and whether it handles assignments like yours. Howler is an Arizona-licensed private investigation agency, license #1821288. For the legal side of choosing an investigator, read Is It Legal to Hire a Private Investigator?, including the boundaries of lawful work and warning signs to watch for.
Then ask the investigator to walk you through the proposed work in plain language:
- What would you check first, and why?
- How would you tell two people with the same name apart or assess whether an address is still relevant?
- What will I receive, and how will the report show which sources support the findings?
Listen for an explanation tied to your situation. If three addresses turn up in a locate, you want to know what makes one worth pursuing. Howler examines details across sources and explains what they add up to. The value is in the analysis: understanding why a lead matters, not simply receiving another address to try.
3. Bring the details that will help the investigator start
For the first conversation, have a short description of the question, any deadline, and a few reliable starting points. Depending on the assignment, those might include a name and spelling variants, a last known city, a business name, or the date of a relevant filing. If a detail came from someone else or may be out of date, say so. Ask how the firm wants to receive sensitive documents before sending them.
Good starting information gives the investigator more to work with; it doesn't have to be a complete file. At Howler, we talk through what you already know and which gaps the research should address.
If you're working with an attorney, ask who should coordinate the assignment and receive the findings. Howler's investigative support for attorneys explains how we work with counsel on factual questions.
4. Agree on the work, the fee, and what you'll get
Before authorizing work, get the scope in writing. It should cover the question being investigated, the work included, the expected timing, the fee, and the deliverable. Ask what would require a new quote or your approval to continue. If you need the findings by a particular date, raise that before you agree to the work.
Howler starts with a free consultation, publishes starting prices, and puts the scope in writing before work begins. Use those prices as a starting point for a conversation about the work your question requires—not as a substitute for an agreed scope.
Compare proposals on more than price. Look at the research included, the analysis you'll receive, and how clearly the investigator explains the assignment. A low fee isn't a bargain if the work doesn't address your question; a high fee doesn't establish quality on its own.
5. Use the findings to make your next decision
Go back to the question you started with. Read the finding that addresses it, look at the supporting sources, and ask about anything that could change your next move.
A recent filing might give you a lead to follow. Conflicting records might tell you exactly which detail needs a second look. Howler's sourced written findings give you a record of what the research supports, so you can discuss the information with counsel, assess a lead, or decide whether more work would help.
Investigators work within legal and privacy limits, and findings depend on the evidence available.